The Problem with Energy Work – According to One Energy Worker

The most well-known form of energy work is probably Reiki. But there are many other modalities that could fit under that umbrella — chakra and aura work, muscle testing, sound healing, breathwork, therapeutic qi gong, acupuncture, massage, homeopathy and some types of botanical treatment.

All of these share one central idea: one person seeks to shift or harmonize the energy of another.

And overall, I think these practices can be deeply helpful — in the right context. When someone finds a modality that truly resonates, it can open the door to real healing. In my view, what we often call “spiritual” work overlaps strongly with physiological safety: parasympathetic activation, emotional regulation, and the gentle processing of subconscious trauma.

Good energy work, at its best, helps us step back from who we think we are and see ourselves from a new lens.

But — as promised in the title — the problem is this: energy work is subtle work.
And subtle things are hard to measure.

I’ve met many so-called energy workers who are, frankly, not very good at what they do but believe themselves to be gifted healers. Because the results of energy work are often subjective and difficult to quantify, even the practitioners themselves may not know when they’re truly helping.

That doesn’t make it impossible to measure — just complicated.
And that complexity often gets bypassed by mutual good intentions.

A client wants to be healed.
A practitioner wants to help.
Both want to believe something meaningful happened.

But two people agreeing that something felt good is not a reliable measure of change.

In my opinion, the real challenge lies not in how to measure, but in who can bear to look. To evaluate your impact honestly, you have to face the possibility that you failed — or worse, that you might have unintentionally caused harm. That’s a serious ego check for anyone attached to being “the intuitive healer” or “the gifted empath.”

The attachment to being a great healer or savior is the biggest blocker to realistic self-evaluation.

Stepping back from that attachment helps you grow — both through more accurate self-assessment and through better client feedback. When clients sense that your self-esteem doesn’t depend on being told the treatment was a success, they’re far more likely to be honest about their experience. That honesty is what allows your work to improve.

For a well-trained dancer, graceful, effortless movements are the result of countless mistakes and long, grueling hours of practice. Similarly, effective energy workers must wrestle with uncertainty.

Since the results aren’t easily measured, a dedicated practitioner should be constantly asking: Did I do it right? That doesn’t mean second-guessing yourself mid-session — confidence is part of the art — but reflection afterward is essential. And the clearest sign you’re doing that well is that it feels uncomfortable.

To care deeply about others while consistently acknowledging uncertainty about your own impact is not an easy path. Real healing work demands that you cultivate a big enough inner container to hold both a passion for healing and uncompromising honesty with yourself.

When I reflect on my time at the National University of Natural Medicine, I saw both options firsthand.

The most popular naturopathic doctors and acupuncturists were often charismatic — near cult figures — utterly confident in their brilliance. Yet there were few, if any, consistent measures showing their “subtle” herbal or homeopathic treatments made a real difference.

The doctors who did make measurable improvements in patient outcomes were different. They were humble. Sometimes anxious. They cared enough to doubt themselves. That anxiety wasn’t weakness — it was evidence of integrity. It pushed them to research more, verify their results, and keep growing.

To sum up, energy work is subtle, and subtle work is inherently hard to measure. With outcomes that lack objective assessment metrics, we must rely on our own intuition, honest reflection, and the sometimes inconsistent feedback of clients. I believe the key—beyond years of study, practice, and hopefully quality mentorship—is cultivating a deeper curiosity for truth than attachment to our own sense of self.

It’s an absurdly large chasm between the sense of oneself as either a gifted healer or delusional quack.

“Energy work is subtle, and subtle work is inherently hard to measure. With outcomes that lack objective assessment metrics, we must rely on our own intuition, honest reflection, and the sometimes inconsistent feedback of clients. I believe the key […] is cultivating a deeper curiosity for truth than attachment to our own sense of self.”

That’s the too-long didn’t read version of today’s blog, “the problem with energy work – according to one energy worker”.

As someone who makes their living doing at least in part some form of energy work, obviously I don’t want the baby thrown out with the bath water, but there’s some junk energy work out there. Let’s talk about it.

Go to: DunbarAcu.com/blog to read more.

Where to Start in Healing: Naturopathic Therapeutic Order

Today’s blog post is a little deep dive into my thought process as influenced by my Naturopathic Doctorate. While there’s a place and a purpose for every part of the pyramid, ideally in non-emergency conditions, the foundational aspects of health are addressed first and indefinitely.

While there’s different wording in my infographic vs chart below, essentially that baseline level is ideally removing whatever obstacle is interfering with the body naturally healing itself. This could be stress, insomnia, or continuing to do intense yard work when your forearms are very adamantly and persistently telling you to take a break (not to call you out Mom).

For many people, there’s things we keep repeatedly being exposed to that keep the dis-ease, pain, suffering, tension, etc. coming back. We might be ignoring our body’s signals to move differently, perhaps ignoring our hearts’ signals to change how we’re working/living, letting our emotions overly affect our diet, and whatever else we’re more attached to than feeling good in our bodymind. This is the best place to focus our efforts for lasting healing.

Certainly more targeted interventions can be necessary, and helpful for starting down a new path, but if the foundational needs for safety and rest aren’t being addressed, problems will keep cropping up no matter how many times we use targeted interventions to keep them at bay.

Feel free to read a bit more below regarding the tiers of intervention and a few notes about how doctors might use this information in practice.

LevelFocus / GoalTypical Interventions or Strategies
1. Remove Obstacles to Health (Remove Obstacles to Cure)Identify and eliminate factors that impair the body’s ability to healDiet & lifestyle changes, reducing toxic exposures, improving sleep, stress reduction, removing emotional/psychological barriers, correcting digestion, eliminating unhelpful habits 2
2. Stimulate the Healing Process (Vis Medicatrix Naturae)Support and prime the body’s innate self-healing forcesGentle therapies: hydrotherapy, nutrition, mild botanical remedies, exposure to nature, energetic modalities, light exercise 3
3. Strengthen Weakened SystemsBuild resilience and capacity in physiological systemsNutritional support, adaptogens, detoxification, supporting liver, immune system, hormonal regulation, antioxidants, lifestyle & restoration measures 4
4. Correct Structural IntegrityRestore proper alignment, mechanical function, and circulationPhysical medicine: chiropractic, osteopathy, massage, postural correction, ergonomics, movement therapies 5
5. Use Natural, Targeted TherapiesWhen necessary, apply more specific natural agents to address pathologyHerbal medicine, specific nutraceuticals, botanicals, other therapies selected for a given condition 6
6. Use Pharmacologic or Synthetic AgentsIn cases where gentler methods are insufficient, use stronger toolsPharmaceuticals, medications, more potent interventions (where within scope/licensing) 7
7. Use Invasive / Surgical / Life-Saving InterventionsThe most forceful or invasive options, when essentialSurgery, radiation, hospitalization, advanced medical interventions, when no less invasive option suffices 8

Notes & caveats

  • The order is not rigid. A patient’s condition may require “jumping” to a higher level sooner (for instance, in emergencies) or combining levels concurrently. 9
  • The principle behind this is to use the least force necessary to achieve healing, minimizing potential harm or side effects. AANMC 10
  • The first step—removing obstacles—is foundational: without clearing the blockages (diet, toxins, stress, structural impediments, etc.), further therapies may be less effective. 11
  • In practice, a naturopath may blend different steps: e.g. they might remove obstacles, stimulate healing, and support weakened systems in parallel, then escalate if needed.

PTSD, Healing & Happy Tears

Crying at the Happy Ending

“Crying at the Happy Ending” is an article by psychoanalyst Joseph Weiss (1952), popularized in Michael Bader’s 2014 article on Psychology Today. Its a powerful piece that explores why, even in the context of watching a movie, we often wait until a resolution to let ourselves feel—and cry.

The core idea is:

  • During the tension or crisis, our nervous system is in survival mode—fight, flight, freeze—so we suppress emotions to stay focused and safe.
  • Once the conflict resolves, we subconsciously perceive safety, and emotions we’ve been holding back—sadness, relief—can finally surface. That release often comes as tears at the happy ending.

Studies and later commentary support this “safety-signal” theory. A neuroscientific review explains that safety signals—learned cues predicting the absence of threat—actively inhibit fear and stress responses in humans and animals. In conditions like PTSD, this safety learning is often impaired, making it difficult to shift out of fear mode (Hamm & Jentsch, 2012).

This idea of emotional release being tied to a sense of safety? It’s not just emotional—it’s physiological. Let’s talk nervous system…


The Body Keeps the Score

As Bessel van der Kolk wrote in The Body Keeps the Score, trauma and chronic stress don’t just live in the mind. They live in the body.

Muscles clench. Breathing gets shallow. The gut stops working smoothly.
We might “move on” intellectually, but the body hasn’t gotten the memo.
Why? Because safety isn’t an idea. It’s a felt experience.

And until the body believes it’s safe, it won’t let go—of tension, pain, or emotion.


This Is the Core of My Work

In my opinion, my #1 priority in the clinic is to create space for my patients to experience a parasympathetic, relaxed sense of safety.

I will often tell my patients, “I take all snoring and drooling as compliments”. And many patients do fall asleep during massage, acupuncture, or cupping treatments.

Sometimes my patients feel more comfortable talking about their lives rather than hitting snooze, and I think that can be helpful as well. The combination of nervous system ease, physical comfort, and open conversation creates a potent cocktail for healing—one that includes both mind and body.

When things get complicated, I return to what I believe is most essential in healing—and in both my personal and professional experience, safety is key.